Showing posts with label gender stereotypes. Show all posts
Showing posts with label gender stereotypes. Show all posts
Monday, 16 July 2012
LEAVING THE NEWSROOM
Last night I watched what will probably be the last episode of The Newsroom that I ever watch, unless some rather extreme circumstances arise. I was considering ranting about why, except this piece by Awards Daily's Sasha Stone both perfectly sums it up, and is from the perspective of someone with a more legit gripe.
Peace, Sork. Hope this is just a blip.
Wednesday, 27 June 2012
I SEE A LOTTA GENDER BINARY LAWBREAKERS OUT THERE: MAGIC MIKE
Box office predictions are not what I do best, largely because I don't really care beyond a vague desire to see good pictures make money and bad ones tank, largely because the predictive metric I use is extremely imprecise: the gut feeling. One's guts, to paraphrase John Cusack in High Fidelity, tend to have shit for brains. But I've been seeing signs that allow me to make the following prediction with a fair degree of confidence: Magic Mike is going to make an absolute fuckton of money.
It will do so by catering to the “people who like seeing good-looking naked dudes” demographic, large numbers of whom have been evincing distinct interest in this movie, and if anything, they're not as excited as they should be. Steven Soderbergh is too subtle a filmmaker to beat a dead horse with enormous stripper cock (though there are a couple, what's the word, memorable dick shots), instead crafting what ends up being a really interesting counterpoint to his January picture Haywire in terms of subversion of traditional notions of gender. Where in Haywire Soderbergh has Gina Carano swaggering around dispensing ownage (traditionally a male enterprise), in Magic Mike we're presented with men who rely on their looks to earn a living dancing naked for money, and the premature obsolescence inherent to that way of life. Much as Gina Carano, while an agent of the highest level of brutal ownage, is also a conventionally attractive, even feminine, woman, Magic Mike star Channing Tatum is in no overt way androgynous, and yet without contradicting his masculinity in any way manages to evince powerful sensuality and vulnerability. However (and sadly tellingly), while Gina Carano's likely career trajectory in movies is essentially “rich man's Cynthia Rothrock,” Channing Tatum's has no ceiling. I've been saying this for a couple years now, but y'all are just gonna have to deal with this shit: Channing Tatum is a good-god-almighty Movie Star.
And he's absolutely tremendous in Magic Mike, a semi-autobiographical tale based loosely on his own days as a male stripper prior to breaking into movies. By day, Tatum is a 30ish guy named Mike hustling a few bucks here and there doing construction and stuff, but by night . . . he's Magic Mike, male stripper extraordinaire. Life is good: he has threesomes with his omnisexual kind-of-sort-of girlfriend Joanna (Olivia Munn) and anonymous women whose names neither of them can remember. One day, Mike meets a younger dude (Alex Pettyfer) who's either shy or has a case of rectal-cranial inversion syndrome—maybe both, but definitely one or the other—and, impulsively, decides to invite him into the odd, hilarious, and wildly fun world of stripping.
Magic Mike's story is nothing especially novel, which in a way is kind of the point. The milieu is relatively novel, as is the fact that it's an examination of male beauty, but the main thrust (heh heh) of the narrative is “life moves on/all things must pass/looks fade/new replaces old.” As the movie goes on, it becomes increasingly clear to Mike that he's rapidly approaching his sell-by date in terms of being a stripper, and the question becomes how exactly he'll deal with this, if in fact he does. Given that this is, while a universal truth, not the most dramatic premise imaginable, Magic Mike is a little slow in places, before recovering for an immensely satisfying ending that vaguely recalls Ron Shelton's Bull Durham, with Channing Tatum as Crash Davis. Of all the things.
Speaking of Tatum, though, the real appeal here is the acting. Tatum is legitimately fucking spectacular, not just in comparison to his previous work, but actually fifth Best Actor nominee caliber. That is not an exaggeration. He hits every note perfectly, from the doofus moments to the puer aeternus moments, to the truly mind-boggling, seemingly physically impossible dance routines (the one he comes up with when Matthew McConaughey challenges him to come up with “something new” truly is something new; Soderbergh shoots it and Tatum performs it in stunning form). The other legitimately award-worthy performance is McConaughey's. His slightly older, semi-retired stripper-turned-majordomo is the absolute perfect Matthew McConaughey role, and not only because he's expressly prohibited from ever wearing a shirt. If anything, McConaughey almost makes it look too easy; the one scene where it's really apparent how much craft is on display is when he and Channing Tatum find themselves, for the first time, overtly at cross purposes. The turn from sexy, charismatic charmer to utterly cold-blooded bastard is immediate, absolute, and perfectly played.
Nearly everyone else is good too. Alex Pettyfer has a slightly tougher job as the inscrutable Kid, and handles himself acceptably. Stand-up comic Gabriel Iglesias represents my people (fat dudes, of course, not Latinos, of whom there are others and of whom despite speaking quite a bit of Spanish I am not) quite well, and hopefully this means he'll get more movie roles, because he's really funny and he does well here. The two main women—apart from the dozens of extras having an absolute goddamn blast during the strip club scenes—are a bit of a study in contrasts: Olivia Munn is fun (and gets the job done, boom bap ba boom ba boom bap) as the threesome-loving Joanna, and looms large in a fairly crucial plot point viz a vis the whole perpetual onward march of time business, though Cody Horn (representing another side of the same plot point) is a bit awkward as the Kid's sister, and makes a bit of a mess with her one big emotional scene. Still, she's not terrible, just not all that great.
The job Steven Soderbergh does with this material is really rather extraordinary. Great as he is, the words “loose” and “fun” are not generally the first that come to mind when his name is mentioned, and the fact that Magic Mike is loose and fun is a lot more surprising than “Peter Andrews” (SERIOUSLY WHY DOES HE ONLY SHOOT STEVEN SODERBERGH MOVIES YOU GUYS????) creating a perfectly Floridian sense of place with a color palate largely grounded in golden browns with the occasional dash of pink (which colors also bring to mind skin), because that's the kinda shit fancy-schmancy really fucking talented filmmakers are supposed to do. The soundtrack is excellent (and a lot more strip-clubby than the usual Soderbergh jazzy David Holmes or ambient Cliff Martinez either-or), and the club sequences are simply goddamn brilliant. American hetero male iconography all over the goddamn place, being made fun of. A shooting style that simultaneously captures the ridiculousness, hilarity, and wonderful guilelessness of the dance numbers. I mean, damn, for a guy who keeps moaning about how he wants to retire, it sure seems like the reason Soderbergh forewent handheld for tripods here is because he kept making the camera shake from giggling nonstop with glee. That authorial sense of fun pervades Magic Mike, and makes the darker parts toward the hour and a quarter mark feel darker. And even at the end, when the irony of the picture's title becomes increasingly manifest, that sense remains, part as a fond memory, part as an indication that what lies ahead may very well be fun, too.
So, yeah. Magic Mike's a real crowd-pleaser. It's on its way to becoming the least-surprising surprise hit in recent memory. Cuz I mean goddamn, for real: you have box-office god Channing Tatum (get used to it) getting very naked (cue straight ladies and gay dudes, “Oh, I can definitely get used to that”) and a lot of other very decorative dudes working without the ol' cis-gender-role safety net. That mix of the familiar and the novel is the stuff genuine blockbusters are made of. Oh, and also, for the lesbians and straight dudes: there are girl boobies, and fairly wonderful ones, too. Just saying, when Magic Mike turns into the biggest non-comic book hit of the summer, don't be shocked.
Tuesday, 17 January 2012
ON GENDER SEMIOTICS, GENRE GENTRIFICATION, AND RAW, UNCUT OWNAGE: HAYWIRE
![]() |
| Spoiler alert: when she catches the guy, she fucks his ass up. |
Oh, Haywire. Where do we begin? With Gina Carano, the newest inductee into the Hall of Ownage? With Steven Soderbergh ticking off another genre conquered? With the utterly bizarre fact that Bill Paxton might give the best performance (and it's not that everybody else sucks, either, terrifyingly)? So much to discuss in a finite universe. The short version is it fucking rocks and you all should see it because it wasn't shot on film or digital video, it was filmed on pure fucking win.
Soderbergh reunited with the writer of The Limey (and opponent in one of the greatest “angry guy vs. passive aggressive wiseass” fights of all time on the DVD commentary track of same), Lem Dobbs, for Haywire, and the result is exactly the kind of cool, flashback-y, intelligent exercise in pure style that, in one's wildest dreams, one hopes for with a new episode of the Lem & Steve show. This one stars retired MMA fighter Gina Carano, whom we learn is an ex-Marine now kicking ass in the private sector, but before anyone even says a word, it's clear that she can (and will) fuck you up.
In a bizarre way, Haywire is of a piece with Soderbergh's Bubble and The Girlfriend Experience, discounting the obvious differences that it has twenty-five times the budget and features wall-to-wall ownage. All three are looks at different variations of being a woman who'd be doing fine if all the fuckin men would stop acting the fool for five seconds, with a protagonist who is not (yet) a professional actor (Sasha Grey got paid to be in movies, but . . . well, let's just say they were in a different genre). However, Gina Carano has a lot more support around her than Debbie Doebereiner (who didn't need any) and Sasha Grey (who could have used a bit more, though she was still better than most critics gave her credit for), as nearly the entire speaking cast are famous dudes, all of whom are terrific: Ewan McGregor, Michael Fassbender, Michael Douglas, Antonio Banderas, all guys we're used to being awesome . . . but then the oddity tier with French filmmaker Mathieu Kassovitz (who also acts occasionally), Bill Paxton (?), and Channing Tatum (???) . . . all of whom are also really good. Mathieu Kassovitz, that makes sense, he's French, that's how they do, but Bill Paxton and Channing Tatum putting in good performances—as Gina Carano's dad and maybe-in-a-parallel-universe-boyfriend type, respectively—that's just silly. And yet, it's true.
The story starts in media res, opening with Gina Carano, established as awesome in one camera move—say, why doesn't that Peter Andrews fellow work more?—tentatively heading into a diner in upstate New York for a cup of tea. Channing Tatum shows up and she's like “shit” (at this point, not knowing what her backstory was, I entertained the possibility she might be a film critic) and Channing Tatum Channing Tatums his way into the diner and a bit of cool oblique spy movie dialogue ensues until it becomes necessary for Gina Carano to unleash holy hell and beat the living shit out of him. He gets in some good shots before she puts him on his ass, at which point she shanghais civilian Michael Angarano, borrows his car, gets him to field dress her arm, and, for reasons that become clear later, tells him her story to date.
It's a humdinger, full of double-crosses, handsome men, copious ownage, and sweet David Holmes music. The kind of picture it is, we should probably leave the plot alone right here, because there are a few good surprises and things that you see coming a mile away where you're like “is this really this obvious or is there another level” and discovering whether they are or not is fun.
Also, as well-constructed as the plot is—and for a boilerplate “one-[wo]man ownage machine fends for [her]self against evil white guys in suits and attempts to restore [her] good name” plot it is well-constructed—the main attraction in Haywire is the execution, and the casual, almost offhand brilliance of the way it deals with gender. Soderbergh understands the genre on a fundamental level. He knows that if you throw in a bunch of windy, didactic dialogue and try to make your statements about gender and genre that way the audience for ownage pictures—not always the most progressive, sadly—is going to start fidgeting and grumbling what the fuck is this bullshit. No, Soderbergh knows the way. Ownage upfront. Gender commentary in the details through the deft use of signifiers.
This is not to say that Haywire isn't entirely about gender. It is. Gina Carano is the only woman in the picture, and being a Soderbergh joint, on a certain level the picture is about Gina Carano as a martial artist playing the lead in an action movie where she's the only woman who owns the bejesus out of all the men, and what that implies for cinema and gender. (Ed. Note: this is why Steven Soderbergh is the fucking best) When Ewan McGregor asks Gina Carano to pretend to be Michael Fassbender's wife for a job, her indignance on being the “eye candy” almost knocks Ewan McGregor through a wall, and she concludes by cracking “Maybe [Michael Fassbender] can wear the dress.”
Gina Carano is absolutely in charge. Channing Tatum? “Sure, I'll hit that.” Michael Fassbender? “Woooooooowwwwwwww, yeah, he's hot.” But always in a very in-control “sure he's hot but if he pulls anything I'll smash his face off something sharp and break every bone in his body and then if I think he's worth wasting a bullet on I'll light him the fuck up” kind of way. But still, as awesome and fully-versed in the fine arts of ownage as she is, the movie does acknowledge the issues inherent to kicking a larger opponent's ass. Some action pictures have 100 lb women punching pro football players in the face and crushing their skulls, which is cool and everything but nonetheless bullshit because physics. Gina Carano looking like a legit athlete (because she is) and being a women's middleweight—which is the same as a dudes' welterweight—eases the suspension of disbelief of something like Salt, with flyweight Angelina Jolie crushing skulls with her fists, slightly. But still, she has to compensate with technique, and this is where being a real martial artist comes in handy. Her moves employ leverage, getting the angle just right, and precision, and then using muscles. At one point, she out-Onatopps Famke Janssen in Goldeneye, asphyxiating [name of actor redacted] between her thighs, which is legendary for the several obvious reasons (ownage/hawwwwwt/Bond reference), but also because the continuity of the run in her tights that results from fighting with the guy is perfect.
And it's little details like that, and the awesome father-daughter relationship between her and Bill Paxton (who's like, “I love my little girl, but she could kung fu me in half without blinking . . . so proud! *wipes away tear*
And this is why Gina Carano is inducted into the Hall of Ownage, on the basis of one lead role only. Even if she does other pictures that suck, she'll always have this. Soderbergh and Dobbs set things up so she doesn't have to do any more acting than she has to, and what little she does have to works within the context of the movie. It also helps that she's got such a great supporting cast, in the truest sense of the term: good actors giving her just the right energy to work with, which is why the idea of a star vehicle starring the least famous person in the movie (another irony Soderbergh no doubt loves) works. It's all set up to make Gina Carano look good, and she does not squander it at all.
(Minor aside here: Michael Douglas is fucking rad as hell in this in the Evil White Guy In A Suit role, that with typical Soderbergh-ian subversiveness may or not be actually evil, but is totally an Evil White Guy In A Suit because Michael Douglas is awesome. In fact, he's playing the James Rebhorn role in this! Rebhorn taught him well. Give me a second to bask in the beauty of the interconnectedness of all things, then let's continue)
I mean, goddamn, Haywire's just about perfect. It's a marvelously tight ownage picture, with a rare compositional clarity and precision of structure that comes from having a really good director in charge. The fact that a director of Steven Soderbergh's stature and talents decided to make an ownage picture is just beautiful, and the fact that he pulled it off so perfectly is no mean feat. May this launch Gina Carano's movie career, and in a different direction than Out of Sight launched Jennifer Lopez, speaking of Steven Soderbergh. But none of that matters. What does is, Haywire is fucking great. Go see it, if you have any interest in things that own.
Wednesday, 12 October 2011
THE DOCTOR IS OUT OF TOUCH
The above is an ad that's been running on TV a bit of late, and has—probably intentionally—provoked a bit of controversy. You may have noticed that I don't talk a whole lot about advertising here, even though it's an occasionally interesting form of cinema, mainly because there's baggage (politics, memetics, aesthetic morality, all kinds of complicated shit). This one, though, requires response, because otherwise I'm going to dent a wall slamming it with my fucking head.
I'm a guy. I like beer. I like sports. I like movies where lots of shit blows up. I'm what you might call, if you felt so fancy, a bit gender normative in all these regards. None of these pleasures induce the slightest bit of guilt. Guilty pleasures are for people who need to loosen the fuck up. By that same token, I'm not one of those morality police-ass motherfuckers always running around telling people, “WAAAAA YOU CAN'T SAY THINK DO OR FEEL THAT BECAUSE OH MY GOD YOU NEED TO BE SENSITIVE WAAAAA” because those people are fucking assholes. When I was a little kid in Park Slope, I went to this mildly schmancy summer arts day camp, which was enlightening and kept me out of trouble when school was out. Being the Slope in the late 80s, it meant there were a whole lot of upper-middle-class junior progressives there, but most of them were okay. The camp people would hook us up with popsicles at the end of the day because it was the summer, and this one day one of the other scruffball troublemaker types I hung around with tossed his popsicle wrapper on the ground. A dick move, and a sign of poor breeding, to be sure, but nothing I was about to break his balls about. This other kid, though, swoops in and in his high-pitched little kid sanctimonious voice squeak-bellows, “YOU LITTERED! THAT'S WRONG! YOU HAVE TO PICK THAT UP AND NEVER DO THAT AGAIN! YOU LITTERED!” I mean, come on. There's politically correct and there's being the little fuck who gets all the extra credit questions right, and this kid was the kind the latter roll their eyes at and call dipshit. Scolding people for bullshit just deepens their resolve to do that kind of shit again.
Then again, right is right and wrong is wrong. Back to that ad for a second. The people who made that ad are operating under all kinds of upfucked assumptions. Let's unpack and dissect:
1—Only dudes like action movies. This right here's about as bullshit as bullshit gets. Due to circumstances beyond my control, I grew up with a dad who didn't really like typical dad stuff. He was indifferent to, if not contemptuous of, sports and the only way you could get him to sit through a violent movie is if it was SF. Thus, my entire responsibility for my early education in both sports and violent movies fell to my mom, who was more than capable of taking care of this, but still, it was all up to her. And it's not like she took this responsibility on because she was on some martyrdom trip, like “in the absence of a traditional male role model, I shall nobly resist and suppress my feminine nature in aid of what must be done for my child.” Fuck that shit, she wanted someone to watch Knicks games and car chase movies with. And as awesome and unconventional as she is, she's not the only woman in the world with these tastes by any means. I get most of my fantasy hockey advice (and not bad at all, either) from a woman friend, and I'm in two different fantasy football leagues with another woman friend, among many other examples. Action movies? Fuckin' forget it, it'd be easier for me to count the number of women I know who don't like violence than the ones that do. Don't even come at me with bullshit about small sample sizes and so forth. Even if you somehow managed to collect stats for the whole movie-watching world and came up with something like less than half women like violent movies, or even if you found out only a third did, you can take that “only dudes like action movies” hooey and jam it in your ass.
2—There is anything manly about drinking diet soda. There are two reasons to drink soda: sugar and caffeine. It is a terrible vehicle for either of these things. If you still need your caffeine fix and for dietary reasons you need to lay off the sugar or something, nut up and drink some fucking black coffee. Putting sugar in your coffee is weakness, and putting milk in it is racist. If you're in a tea-drinking country, tea's fine, just put like twelve bags in the kettle and get ready for fucking liftoff. Relying on soda for caffeine is like jerking off with the crook of your elbow.
3—This “no women allowed” thing. Now, this'd be a whole 'nother deal if Dr. Pepper was like, “you know what? With the number of states passing marriage equality votes, and with the repeal of Don't Ask Don't Tell finally allowing members of the military to come out, let's reach out and market our new diet soft drink to gay men.” Which would be just as dumb, because then you'd be shafting the lesbians, and their whole trip is that that's not their trip. There's no way this “no women allowed” shit isn't sexist. At all. There are nights you hang out with your dudes, or your chicks, and it's just dudes or just chicks, and that is what it is, but if you're some dude hanging with your dudes and you're saying (or, shit, thinking) “Fuck yeah, bro, I'm fuckin glad as fuck there aren't any fucking chicks around bro, fuck that shit, bros before hoes, bro, fuck yeah!” you need to broaden your horizons. You may even find a female friend who finds your double entendres about broadening your horizons by hanging out with broads funny. (Ed. Note: I'm living proof!)
Ad people are probably looking at all the people tweeting and blogging about how fucking stupid this is and going “Well, the spot did its job, people are talking.” Here's the problem with that assumption: all the people talking about this are pissed. They're not going to suddenly want to have makeup sex with this dumb diet soda. And, on the off chance, some dumbfuck bro types are sitting around going “Fuck yeah, bro,” those dummies aren't about to go drink this piss. They're barely going to remember what the fucking ad was for thirty seconds later. The net result is, you pissed a bunch of people off for nothing. All because you couldn't be fucking bothered to think about what human beings are like beyond a stereotypical level.
Rather than end on an angry note, let me raise a glass to all the women out there who like action movies. Let me raise another glass to the men who aren't so stunned by that affinity that they treat those women like unicorns, and instead do the sensible thing and kick it about action movies with them. Let's raise a glass to treating people like human fucking beings. And rest assured, what is in the glass I raise will not be Dr. Pepper.
Monday, 16 May 2011
THERE IS NO SUCH THING AS A CHICK FLICK

The release this weekend of Bridesmaids, from the Judd Apatow comedy factory, started a lot of discussions about whether or not men will go see movies starring and created by women. That a lot of dudes stood up and went “yeah, I'm a dude and I'll go see that movie” may be more a function of it being a Judd Apatow factory movie than an outbreak of gender progressivism, but fuck it. Rome wasn't built in a day, dudes went to see a movie written by women, Bridesmaids made money. All the hand-wringing turned out to be for nothing. But let us, for fuck's sake, retire the phrase “chick flick.”
It's a problematic term because it's so nebulous and, for lack of a better word, broad. Everyone's got a different definition, be it the “yah bro” backwards-baseball-cap-with-red-plastic-drink-cup version (roughly “anything with chicks as anything other than a trophy or sex fantasy”) or the one this girl I went on one date with proffered defensively/defiantly: “I don't really care about movies, I like chick flicks” (I was polite, but there was no second date). Depending who you ask, it's restricted to movies with Kate Hudson or Katherine Heigl in them, or it's any movie with a woman in the lead. It's nearly always a diminutive, and almost certainly owes the longevity of its use to the fact that it rhymes. “Chick flick.” It's snappy. Sharp consonants, two syllables. And utterly devoid of meaning.
There are a few reasons I hate the phrase “chick flick” so much. I almost never personally use the word “flick” to talk about movies, just like I almost never use the word “film” (the latter is something I'm trying to reintegrate, because there are whole conversations you can't have without using, for example, the phrase “an Ingmar Bergman film,” because there's no other way to describe what that dude made, he made films, just like Robert Bresson, Satyajit Ray, and a handful of other people . . . anyway, enough of that shit, back to the world “flick.”) That's not the problem with the phrase, though. I can get over my personal shit. It's the shortcut to thinking, jettisoning nuance and specificity for the sake of simplicity. It'd be one thing if this was an actual term any two people were able to actually define the same way. But in this case it's like, “Huh huh huh, fuck that shit, that's a chick flick,” and not only do you sound like a fucking retard, you haven't conveyed anything.
Most of the time, I'll grant, people are talking about a couple specific kinds of pictures:
1—a romantic comedy where the boy-crazy, materialistic, pratfall-prone pathological liar heroine gets some dude to de-nut himself and fall in love with her.
2—tragic melodramas where everyone dies at the end
3—revenge things where the chick wins and the dudes lose
4—anything with lesbians in it that isn't porn
5—anything with subtitles in it that doesn't feature Asian people beating the fucking shit out of each other.
The problem with these archetypes is that with the exception of 1) and maybe 4) these end up describing lots of things that aren't “chick flicks” and I'd submit that chicks shouldn't have to take the blame for 1). That description is of a bad movie, irrespective of gender. Those kinds of pictures, which nearly every actress between the ages of 18 and 40 gets talked into doing by her lizard fuckface agent, get made because they reinforce all kinds of shit that's convenient for multinational corporations to reinforce: materialism, heteronormativity, hewing to tradition, etc. Audiences go to see them because they don't challenge anything about the way they see the world, and studios keep making them because audiences keep going to see them.
That one specific, cynically motivated, utterly fucking horrible kind of movie is what passes for a romantic comedy nowadays, which is a goddamn shame because there have been some truly wonderful romantic comedies made over the years. It's why it's very difficult to get a lot of guys to admit that they like “romantic comedies” and at best they'll cop to liking one or two as aberrations. You could make the argument that this is typical regressive dude bullshit, insecurity about masculinity and blah blah blah, but the actual reason for this is that in every single crappy romantic comedy ever made, the guys are all either total pussies, the sassy gay best friend, or one-dimensionally evil. Or all three.
Now, men being marginalized isn't exactly the same as women being marginalized/objectified in “male” movies, because of power dynamics and privilege and all that, and if we're to correct this problem in movies marketed to women, there needs to be a similar correction in movies marketed to men. Ideally, we'd have movies where the men and women alike are three-dimensional, exist for their own purpose rather than as a function of another's necessity, and are recognizable as human beings. It's okay, I'll give you a second to stop laughing.
But really, why the fuck do all movies have to be “for” only one type of person? Women go see movies with dude protagonists all the time. And dudes will go see movies with women protagonists: Aliens didn't exactly flop, nor did Kill Bill, nor did Salt, which I just saw a couple days ago (I greatly enjoyed it, it's glorious horseshit). True, those are all action pictures. But by the broadest definition of “chick flick,” all three qualify. They feature women in the lead, and Kill Bill and Salt both feature those women killing the fuck out of guys who screwed them over (Aliens, of course, features Sigourney Weaver killing the fuck out of aliens). “But they're not chick flicks! They're good!” Well, if being good stops something from being a chick flick, maybe there's no such thing as a chick flick. Maybe movies are either good or bad, and that's the only important thing.
Men and women are different. But each man is different from each other man, and each woman different from each other woman. I know dudes who like movies where shit blows up, I know other dudes who prefer Guy Maddin “everybody's in Canada and only has one leg” pictures. I know chicks who rave about how fuken awesome and metal Game of Thrones is and catch me up on who's who and how the names are spelled and shit, I know others who can't watch it because of the way the female characters are portrayed. Flip the genders and each four of those examples is true of at least one other friend of mine on the other side. The point is, generalizations are for fucking retards. Including that one.
So what of Bridesmaids? As your slide rule no doubt told you, I don't give a fuck whether it's a “chick flick” or not. From all accounts Kristen Wiig and her co-writer were just trying to write a funny script. That's all I care about this movie, or any other for that matter. Is it good? All that other divisive bullshit, who it's “for” and so forth, doesn't interest me at all. If you build it (with “build” meaning “make” and “it” meaning “a good movie”), I'll come (with “come” meaning “enjoy it,” and by “enjoy it” I mean achieve orgasm). Fuck “chick flicks.” Fuck “bro movies.” Let's just go to the fucking movies and enjoy ourselves. Is that too much to ask?
Wednesday, 25 August 2010
BETTER LIVING THROUGH NETFLIX VOL. 5: A MYSTERY GUEST
Ordinarily, I would eat somebody alive for panning a movie they didn't sit all the way through. I'm getting around that by not talking about the movie itself, but rather the overall DVD experience. As it so often does, it starts with the trailers:
Did You Hear About The Morgans?
Let's clarify. This movie doesn't actually exist; it's actually a bleeding-edge multimedia art project/political statement about the stupidity of Hollywood. The proof is right in the trailer. There's no way this is actually a movie. It's too perfectly calculated a trailer—that opening bit with Hugh Grant and his bitch-boy is a joke with a narrative arc, beginning with a lame, contrived set-up, allowing Hugh to flash some sandpaper wit, all concluding with a reference to a “relationship.” Because OMG U GUISE ITS A ROEMANTIK COMEDEE LOL.
So let's see . . . somebody gets killed and Hugh Grant and Sarah Jessica O'Horseface have to go into the witness protection program. In The Country! Sarah Jessica McFuckball makes a Sarah Palin joke (edgy!) And Hugh Grant and SJP fall back in love. It all gets very frantic and splintered by the end of the trailer, just like the third acts of the movies this avant-garde experiment is satirizing.
Here's the kicker, though. Because the movie itself is of so little importance in modern Hollywood, the centerpiece of the experiment was its original release date. Yes, that's right, DYHATM? was “released” the same day as Avatar. And sure, Avatar ended up being fucking terrible (Ed. Note: Avatar is really, really, really, really awful) but if there was one thing you could set your clock by in the industry, it was that anyone who went to a movie that weekend was going to see Avatar. It had been marketed just right, with just the right level of cultural saturation, and managed to convince people that they were excited.
And this is the final, clinching piece of evidence for Did You Hear About The Morgans? being an experiment commenting on bad marketing campaigns: everything about it fucking sucks. Has anyone given a flaming rat's ass about Hugh Grant in 15 years? No. Does anyone actually like Sarah Jessica Blah-Blah-Blah? Sure the show was a hit, but Kim Cattrall was the one everyone was actually interested in. The bit about giving away the entire plot in the trailer is but the capstone on the whole experiment; why would anyone want to spend two hours what they just saw in a minute and a half?
Ice Castles
Promising young skater gets injured, comes back triumphantly? I really can't tell. Drowning under mountains of goopy sentimentality, kinda pissed about this being another trailer that gives the whole movie away. But there is a place for a PG family movie with an unchallenging, diagrammatic structure about a nice girl “positive role model” type. That place just happens to be elsewhere than my DVD player.
Sleepless in Seattle
Okay, what the fuck? Bear in mind, at this point, I have literally forgotten what DVD I put in the player. It's late, I'm a little addled (actually just plain old exhaustion rather than booze or drugs), but still, it's a little alarming that I can't remember what movie's going to be coming on in 5 minutes. I also am at a a bit of a loss as to why a trailer for a movie that came out in 1993 is in front of the same movie as something that came out last December (and whenever the Ice Castles thing came out, it looks recent too).
Eventually, I get distracted by remembering how good Sleepless in Seattle was. Oh, that bygone era, when Tom Hanks had just become the massive movie star he always should have been, when Meg Ryan was Meg Ryan, and the romantic comedy formula had yet to devolve into the disturbing mess that it is today. Though, in a way, Sleepless in Seattle established the template for the “this isn't romantic, these people are actually out of their fucking minds” modern rom-com. Meg Ryan happens to hear Tom Hanks talking about his late wife on a talk radio show, falls in love with him, and kind of starts stalking him. Meg Ryan was only able to get away with this because she's Meg Ryan, but Sleepless in Seattle was a hit, so dozens more movies with lesser movie stars were made where the insanity of the heroine's actions wasn't offset by Meg Ryan's preternaturally adorable Meg Ryan-ness.
Actually, before the feature presentation even started, during the Sleepless in Seattle trailer, I started wondering about Nora Ephron. In When Harry Met Sally, she did a fairly decent job with her male characters, even though the scene where Billy Crystal and Bruno Kirby are talking about Billy's divorce at a Giants game would never happen (dudes talk about chick shit during a game about as often as solar eclipses), though the fact that the dialogue rings true helps.
But Sleepless in Seattle sees Nora slip a little bit more. Rob Reiner, as Tom Hanks' buddy, is a character who simply does not exist. Dudes do not have girl talk with each other. The couple clips of Tom Hanks and Rob Reiner in the trailer consist entirely of them having girl talk. Now, in the movie itself, this actually works, as the movie is a very otherworldly, stylized thing, and is a lot more self-reflexively meta-cinematic than the average early 90s studio picture. But, in hindsight, it's a sign that Nora Ephron was slipping just a hair.
Guy writers frequently get criticized for not writing good women, or writing women who are little more than fantasy objects. Hey, I've consciously written women characters as fantasy objects before, I'm not saying I'm above such missteps. Women do it too, though. A woman writing a scene where two dudes talk articulately about their feelings and ask each other if their butt looks cute (admittedly, a pretty funny scene in SiS) is equally as fantastic as a man writing a scene where two femme chicks spontaneously start making out. Both have possibly happened at some point or other in real life. Possibly. However, as a writer, you should always be aware of how farfetched such a premise is.
Also, let's note another fuckup that doesn't really count because it was funny: dudes don't cry at the end of the Dirty Dozen, much as it worked as a joke in this. Dudes cry at the end of Field of Dreams, which is actually more limpdick, so props to Nora Ephron for letting us save testicular face.
(Ed. Note: all this negativity about Nora Ephron and Sleepless in Seattle is just foreshadowing—Sleepless in Seattle's pretty fuckin good)
Hanging Up
Huh. Another Nora Ephron movie? What the fuck is going on here? (Ed. Note: at this point, the author has still yet to remember what movie he just put in the DVD player). The only thing I really remember about this one was that it took that meta-cinematic feel Sleepless in Seattle had to a whole 'nother level, making the importance of the characters' resemblance to real people secondary to the importance of their resembling movie characters. Which, yeah, is interesting if you're high, and Meg Ryan, Diane Keaton, and Lisa Kudrow are all cool, I guess, but really, when I'm high I either want to be watching art pictures from the 60s or John Lithgow invading Earth with a fake Italian accent. Personal prejudice.
And, our feature presentation . . . Julie & Julia
Hey, don't look at me, I don't know why the fuck I Netflixed this. At the same time, they sent it to me, I hadn't seen it, I figured, why not? Maybe it'll be good. The Nora Ephron trailers suddenly made sense, and that odd parallel-universe feeling I'd been having eased somewhat.
But holy shit, this movie wasn't messing around when it decided to suck. From the word go, everything is completely stilted and artificial. Amy Adams' friends seem to have beamed in from some parallel universe where people declaim instead of conversing. Amy Adams, herself, does an excellent job, but she has a bit of trouble rolling the rock up the mountain with this fuckin' dialogue.
Meryl's great, and seeing her and Stanley Tucci so mad for each other is cool, but it can't shake how godawful the Amy Adams & co. bits are in the first half hour or so, which is all I made it through. It was too painful to watch something so completely divorced from reality, and the irony that it was based on a true story made me need a drink.
Now, of course, it's possible that the movie abruptly becomes awesome at some point after I turned it off. Even though I doubt that it does, that's neither here nor there because I didn't actually take the time to find out.
Still, that being said, it's unfortunate that Nora Ephron lost her fastball, because as stylized and non-naturalistic as When Harry Met Sally and Sleepless in Seattle were, they were still really fucking funny. Of course, Julie & Julia isn't a laff-a-minute farce—its intention is to be a story with funny bits in it rather than a straight-up comedy—but even the stuff that's supposed to be funny is strained, and so far removed from actual human experience that it's like “Okay . . . I guess . . .” whereas When Harry Met Sally was like “Wow, I never thought of it that way before!”
The most interesting thing about experiencing the (incomplete) picture in this fashion was the narrative created by the trailers. We started with a great example of the modern romantic comedy—manic, joyless, insane, devoid of both romance and comedy—progress to a feel-good programmer (hey, civilians need shit to enjoy too), then the tripartite Nora Ephron show. All told, it was only an hour or so out of my life, so I don't feel like I totally wasted an evening or anything, but boy it was weird and inexplicably kind of disturbing to see that drift away from reality.
Oh, well. That happened. Moving on . . .
Did You Hear About The Morgans?
Let's clarify. This movie doesn't actually exist; it's actually a bleeding-edge multimedia art project/political statement about the stupidity of Hollywood. The proof is right in the trailer. There's no way this is actually a movie. It's too perfectly calculated a trailer—that opening bit with Hugh Grant and his bitch-boy is a joke with a narrative arc, beginning with a lame, contrived set-up, allowing Hugh to flash some sandpaper wit, all concluding with a reference to a “relationship.” Because OMG U GUISE ITS A ROEMANTIK COMEDEE LOL.
So let's see . . . somebody gets killed and Hugh Grant and Sarah Jessica O'Horseface have to go into the witness protection program. In The Country! Sarah Jessica McFuckball makes a Sarah Palin joke (edgy!) And Hugh Grant and SJP fall back in love. It all gets very frantic and splintered by the end of the trailer, just like the third acts of the movies this avant-garde experiment is satirizing.
Here's the kicker, though. Because the movie itself is of so little importance in modern Hollywood, the centerpiece of the experiment was its original release date. Yes, that's right, DYHATM? was “released” the same day as Avatar. And sure, Avatar ended up being fucking terrible (Ed. Note: Avatar is really, really, really, really awful) but if there was one thing you could set your clock by in the industry, it was that anyone who went to a movie that weekend was going to see Avatar. It had been marketed just right, with just the right level of cultural saturation, and managed to convince people that they were excited.
And this is the final, clinching piece of evidence for Did You Hear About The Morgans? being an experiment commenting on bad marketing campaigns: everything about it fucking sucks. Has anyone given a flaming rat's ass about Hugh Grant in 15 years? No. Does anyone actually like Sarah Jessica Blah-Blah-Blah? Sure the show was a hit, but Kim Cattrall was the one everyone was actually interested in. The bit about giving away the entire plot in the trailer is but the capstone on the whole experiment; why would anyone want to spend two hours what they just saw in a minute and a half?
Ice Castles
Promising young skater gets injured, comes back triumphantly? I really can't tell. Drowning under mountains of goopy sentimentality, kinda pissed about this being another trailer that gives the whole movie away. But there is a place for a PG family movie with an unchallenging, diagrammatic structure about a nice girl “positive role model” type. That place just happens to be elsewhere than my DVD player.
Sleepless in Seattle
Okay, what the fuck? Bear in mind, at this point, I have literally forgotten what DVD I put in the player. It's late, I'm a little addled (actually just plain old exhaustion rather than booze or drugs), but still, it's a little alarming that I can't remember what movie's going to be coming on in 5 minutes. I also am at a a bit of a loss as to why a trailer for a movie that came out in 1993 is in front of the same movie as something that came out last December (and whenever the Ice Castles thing came out, it looks recent too).
Eventually, I get distracted by remembering how good Sleepless in Seattle was. Oh, that bygone era, when Tom Hanks had just become the massive movie star he always should have been, when Meg Ryan was Meg Ryan, and the romantic comedy formula had yet to devolve into the disturbing mess that it is today. Though, in a way, Sleepless in Seattle established the template for the “this isn't romantic, these people are actually out of their fucking minds” modern rom-com. Meg Ryan happens to hear Tom Hanks talking about his late wife on a talk radio show, falls in love with him, and kind of starts stalking him. Meg Ryan was only able to get away with this because she's Meg Ryan, but Sleepless in Seattle was a hit, so dozens more movies with lesser movie stars were made where the insanity of the heroine's actions wasn't offset by Meg Ryan's preternaturally adorable Meg Ryan-ness.
Actually, before the feature presentation even started, during the Sleepless in Seattle trailer, I started wondering about Nora Ephron. In When Harry Met Sally, she did a fairly decent job with her male characters, even though the scene where Billy Crystal and Bruno Kirby are talking about Billy's divorce at a Giants game would never happen (dudes talk about chick shit during a game about as often as solar eclipses), though the fact that the dialogue rings true helps.
But Sleepless in Seattle sees Nora slip a little bit more. Rob Reiner, as Tom Hanks' buddy, is a character who simply does not exist. Dudes do not have girl talk with each other. The couple clips of Tom Hanks and Rob Reiner in the trailer consist entirely of them having girl talk. Now, in the movie itself, this actually works, as the movie is a very otherworldly, stylized thing, and is a lot more self-reflexively meta-cinematic than the average early 90s studio picture. But, in hindsight, it's a sign that Nora Ephron was slipping just a hair.
Guy writers frequently get criticized for not writing good women, or writing women who are little more than fantasy objects. Hey, I've consciously written women characters as fantasy objects before, I'm not saying I'm above such missteps. Women do it too, though. A woman writing a scene where two dudes talk articulately about their feelings and ask each other if their butt looks cute (admittedly, a pretty funny scene in SiS) is equally as fantastic as a man writing a scene where two femme chicks spontaneously start making out. Both have possibly happened at some point or other in real life. Possibly. However, as a writer, you should always be aware of how farfetched such a premise is.
Also, let's note another fuckup that doesn't really count because it was funny: dudes don't cry at the end of the Dirty Dozen, much as it worked as a joke in this. Dudes cry at the end of Field of Dreams, which is actually more limpdick, so props to Nora Ephron for letting us save testicular face.
(Ed. Note: all this negativity about Nora Ephron and Sleepless in Seattle is just foreshadowing—Sleepless in Seattle's pretty fuckin good)
Hanging Up
Huh. Another Nora Ephron movie? What the fuck is going on here? (Ed. Note: at this point, the author has still yet to remember what movie he just put in the DVD player). The only thing I really remember about this one was that it took that meta-cinematic feel Sleepless in Seattle had to a whole 'nother level, making the importance of the characters' resemblance to real people secondary to the importance of their resembling movie characters. Which, yeah, is interesting if you're high, and Meg Ryan, Diane Keaton, and Lisa Kudrow are all cool, I guess, but really, when I'm high I either want to be watching art pictures from the 60s or John Lithgow invading Earth with a fake Italian accent. Personal prejudice.
And, our feature presentation . . . Julie & Julia
Hey, don't look at me, I don't know why the fuck I Netflixed this. At the same time, they sent it to me, I hadn't seen it, I figured, why not? Maybe it'll be good. The Nora Ephron trailers suddenly made sense, and that odd parallel-universe feeling I'd been having eased somewhat.
But holy shit, this movie wasn't messing around when it decided to suck. From the word go, everything is completely stilted and artificial. Amy Adams' friends seem to have beamed in from some parallel universe where people declaim instead of conversing. Amy Adams, herself, does an excellent job, but she has a bit of trouble rolling the rock up the mountain with this fuckin' dialogue.
Meryl's great, and seeing her and Stanley Tucci so mad for each other is cool, but it can't shake how godawful the Amy Adams & co. bits are in the first half hour or so, which is all I made it through. It was too painful to watch something so completely divorced from reality, and the irony that it was based on a true story made me need a drink.
Now, of course, it's possible that the movie abruptly becomes awesome at some point after I turned it off. Even though I doubt that it does, that's neither here nor there because I didn't actually take the time to find out.
Still, that being said, it's unfortunate that Nora Ephron lost her fastball, because as stylized and non-naturalistic as When Harry Met Sally and Sleepless in Seattle were, they were still really fucking funny. Of course, Julie & Julia isn't a laff-a-minute farce—its intention is to be a story with funny bits in it rather than a straight-up comedy—but even the stuff that's supposed to be funny is strained, and so far removed from actual human experience that it's like “Okay . . . I guess . . .” whereas When Harry Met Sally was like “Wow, I never thought of it that way before!”
The most interesting thing about experiencing the (incomplete) picture in this fashion was the narrative created by the trailers. We started with a great example of the modern romantic comedy—manic, joyless, insane, devoid of both romance and comedy—progress to a feel-good programmer (hey, civilians need shit to enjoy too), then the tripartite Nora Ephron show. All told, it was only an hour or so out of my life, so I don't feel like I totally wasted an evening or anything, but boy it was weird and inexplicably kind of disturbing to see that drift away from reality.
Oh, well. That happened. Moving on . . .
Friday, 8 January 2010
THE FIVE WORST DATE MOVIES (BY WHICH I MEAN SIX)
In honor of Friday night, as I sit comfortably at home listening to Englishmen with drug problems doing wondrous things to guitars, the topic of date movies presents itself. The boilerplate for this murkily defined genre—stories about people in love that make girls cry and squeeze their boyfriend’s hand—is not my main area of expertise. Most of the women I hang around with want to go see the same kind of movies I do: the kind with explosions and people killing shit. This goes for the gay men I know too—my closest friend of whom is a fellow Tony Scott disciple and makes fun of me for knowing more about Joan Crawford and Bette Davis than he does.
So why am I—uniquely unqualified to discuss a normal date not only due to the above-mentioned circumstances but also my emotionally remote, self-conscious nature—talking about date movies? Because I’m talking about the worst ones. I’m talking about movies that couldn’t get you laid in a thousand years. I’m talking about movies that if you watch them at home on DVD while fucking will inspire your partner to ceasefire immediately and leave. That will cause fights. That will just make you feel ooky.
Before getting to the list proper, a couple surprise omissions:
Schindler’s List (dir. Steven Spielberg)—1993
Would be number one, but Jerry Seinfeld hooked up to it once. Sure, he and the chick he hooked up with weren’t watching it, but still. Disqualification’s a disqualification.
Total Recall (dir. Paul Verhoeven)—1990
I hooked up to this movie once. I am, of course, a god.
* * * *
So now, the list proper:
(5) Chasing Amy (dir. Kevin Smith)—1997
This came out (ba dump bump) the middle of my freshman year at Bard College, a place where the fine tradition of collegiate lesbianism was (and, I presume, still is) devoutly observed. In spite of writer-director Kevin Smith’s best efforts, the sisters were not amused. Two of same, a couple with whom I was friendly, asked me whether I thought Chasing Amy was worth seeing. I thought about it for a second—I knew it was a really bad idea, but I’ve got troll blood pumping through my veins—and told them sure, all the controversy was just Harvey Weinstein publicity. Fast-forward to a few hours later: I’ve turned in early (in retrospect, a sign something was seriously wrong) and just fallen asleep when BAM BAM BAM BAM BAM “DANNY, I KNOW YOU’RE IN THERE!” Apparently, the movie disturbed the two of them so much that they almost broke up three times in the car on the way home (once when one of them blamed the other for “her friend”—me—playing such a horrible prank on them, the second when the other blamed the first for being friends with me, and the third just because they were being emotional) and wanted to lecture me about how horrible and homophobic the movie was, and how men may not understand this but lesbians do not have any interest in men! Harrumph! (Postscript: one of them is now married to a man). So yeah.
Lest we assume from that anecdote that only lesbian couples will react this badly to Chasing Amy, an apparently straight woman I watched it with later told me as she rolled her eyes “you only like this because it’s about lesbians . . . god, men are all alike.” Steer clear. It also hasn't aged very well.
(4) The Hunt For Red October (dir. John McTiernan)—1990
This one’s strictly speculative, and it’s admittedly standing in for a litany of—for the purposes under discussion—interchangeable military-themed pictures, and this one wins the prize for being one of my favorites. But I can’t imagine being sober and/or remotely giving a shit and suggesting to a date that we watch this. Unless there’s some girl out there who gets all squirmy at the sound of James Earl Jones saying, “Now understand, the torpedo did not detonate, you heard it hit the hull. And I . . . was never here.” (If you do, e-mail me). The exquisite pleasures of watching fiercely intelligent men match wits, maverick Soviet sub captains evading capture and certain death from all sides, callow young CIA analysts struggling to earn the trust of veteran military men, and ultimately basking quietly in a shared victory are in completely separate categories from the exquisite pleasures of taking women to bed. Do not mix.
(3) Sid and Nancy (dir. Alex Cox)—1986
As with (4), this one is standing in for any number of movies with a similar problem, but this goes one higher on the list because while gay military nerds might get simultaneous boners to all the talk about Crazy Ivans and so forth, watching a couple get so fucked up on drugs that the guy fatally stabs the girl is not getting anyone hot. Not to mention, Pistols purists occasionally gripe about the liberties Alex Cox took with the historical record in favor of hallucinatory visuals and general narrative drive, so try and seduce them some other way. Still, that caveat aside, it’s a great movie, and endlessly quotable, but when one of the best quotes is “None of us fuck, see? Sex is ugly,” it’s maybe kind of sort just slightly advisable to not try and get someone turned on with this one. Try, I don’t know, Trainspotting, that at least has Ewan McGregor’s dick in it.
(2) Caddyshack (dir. Harold Ramis)—1980*
Now, I know what you’re thinking—Rodney does cap the proceedings by announcing: “Hey, everybody. We’re all gonna get laid!” And yes, that is the greatest last line in a movie ever. But, reasonable as it may seem to turn to your girl after Rodney says the line and say to her, “So . . . is he right?” I would advise against. Also, this is the one movie I can think of that I have absolutely never met a woman who liked it. At all. I speak as a guy who has made out with a girl while watching Slap Shot and even—put the bullshit detector away, please—once met a girl who liked Bloodsport. So as an expert on such matters, do not, gentlemen, ask your girl to sit through Caddyshack. You will not be pleased with the results.
(2a) Fried Green Tomatoes (dir. Jon Avnet)—1991
Since the above paragraph was directed solely to men, a word for the ladies: making a guy watch this movie is like taking him shopping. Now, I’m a progressive guy, and as sophisticated a cineaste as you’re going to find anywhere (the ten “fucks” per sentence and wide-eyed fascination with explosions and car chases notwithstanding). This is a well-made movie. It’s got a terrific cast. I am not in any way shape or form knocking it as a movie. But as an experience, if you’re not a woman, this movie is not interested in you. Never mind that a guy directed it. A woman directed Point Break, after all. I had an ex put Fried Green Tomatoes on once, and she woke me up to complain that she’d wanted to watch a movie as a romantic evening together. Let the record reflect that it did not work.
(2) and (2a) are part of the same point—any movie that caters entirely to the interests of one gender fails as a date movie. Apologies for any slight to gay couples, but the same principle would apply to any movie with an aggressively and exclusively heteronormative viewpoint, or, worse, an openly homophobic one. I’d come up with a specific example, but as I said before, the only gay guy I watch a lot of movies with spends all his time trying to figure out whether Dario Argento or Takashi Miike is the greatest director of all time and I'm still persona non grata with the lesbians over shit like the Chasing Amy trolling, so I don’t really have a normal demographic sample to work with here.
(1) Knocked Up (dir. Judd Apatow)—2007
The absolute worst date movie imaginable. Forget for a second that Judd Apatow movies are all too long, and his process—building the movie around improvised scenes—inexorably leads to a loose, digressive narrative structure. Hell, John Cassavetes movies are all too long, what are you gonna do, call the cops? Forget also that in spite of at least one hilarious scene per movie (i.e. “You know how I know you’re gay?” or “Munich is going to get us laid!”) there are just as invariably excruciatingly long stretches of maudlin sentimentality or leaden moodiness in each one. That could happen to anybody, and as the man said, dying is easy, comedy’s hard. No, that’s not the worst. Hell, 40 Year Old Virgin is actually not a bad date movie, all things considered. But Knocked Up has a number of jaw-droppers in store for a couple going to see it on their first or second date:
--The whole story revolves around a fun, drunken hookup wherein the guy gets the girl pregnant. In and of itself that would make it the worst date movie ever, but it doesn’t stop there.
--All the guys are emotionally retarded pussies.
--The women don’t fare much better. Katherine Heigl’s ok, and you gotta cut her some slack for being pissed off about getting pregnant, which sucks, but holy shit Leslie Mann got stuck with a thankless part. All she does the whole movie is either scream at people or cry. She’s such a fascistic wife that Paul Rudd has to sneak off to his fantasy baseball draft like it was an adulterous affair.
--The ultimate conclusion seems to be that men are emotionally stunted boy-pupae who with the help of a woman telling them what do to, can blossom into husband-butterflies.
Now, it can be argued—probably pretty easily—that I’m overreacting, that that’s not what Judd Apatow is saying. That’s not the point (and it’s not just not the point because it’s flimsy bullshit). The clincher is: there was a lot of talk in the media when Knocked Up came out about it provoking serious conversations between couples who went to see it on dates. This is why it’s the worst date movie ever. Serious conversations???? Serious conversations are for when you’re already in a relationship. Dates are supposed to be about going out, having a good time—drinking, dancing, eating good food, having a laugh, getting in adventures, etc.—not sitting around debating the nature of gender roles in modern society.
Not only that, but the biggest problem with all the men in Knocked Up being pussies/retards/both and all the women being angry/dictatorial/pathologically vague about their wants is that, unlike (2) and (2a) where at least one person is being entertained, both of you are being insulted.
* * * *
In the end, the solution is to either date someone who likes the same kind of movies you do, trade off who gets to pick the movie, or just avoid the minefield altogether and think of something else to do. Don’t ask me what that is; if I knew I wouldn’t be writing a movie blog.
****
*(EDIT (1/11/10): The other night my friends Hope Cartelli and Jessi Gotta brought it to my attention that this is bullshit: they're both women and they both love Caddyshack. Moreover, Jessi tells me it was her mother who got her into it. So, a revision: only really cool girls like Caddyshack.)
So why am I—uniquely unqualified to discuss a normal date not only due to the above-mentioned circumstances but also my emotionally remote, self-conscious nature—talking about date movies? Because I’m talking about the worst ones. I’m talking about movies that couldn’t get you laid in a thousand years. I’m talking about movies that if you watch them at home on DVD while fucking will inspire your partner to ceasefire immediately and leave. That will cause fights. That will just make you feel ooky.
Before getting to the list proper, a couple surprise omissions:
Schindler’s List (dir. Steven Spielberg)—1993
Would be number one, but Jerry Seinfeld hooked up to it once. Sure, he and the chick he hooked up with weren’t watching it, but still. Disqualification’s a disqualification.
Total Recall (dir. Paul Verhoeven)—1990
I hooked up to this movie once. I am, of course, a god.
* * * *
So now, the list proper:
(5) Chasing Amy (dir. Kevin Smith)—1997
This came out (ba dump bump) the middle of my freshman year at Bard College, a place where the fine tradition of collegiate lesbianism was (and, I presume, still is) devoutly observed. In spite of writer-director Kevin Smith’s best efforts, the sisters were not amused. Two of same, a couple with whom I was friendly, asked me whether I thought Chasing Amy was worth seeing. I thought about it for a second—I knew it was a really bad idea, but I’ve got troll blood pumping through my veins—and told them sure, all the controversy was just Harvey Weinstein publicity. Fast-forward to a few hours later: I’ve turned in early (in retrospect, a sign something was seriously wrong) and just fallen asleep when BAM BAM BAM BAM BAM “DANNY, I KNOW YOU’RE IN THERE!” Apparently, the movie disturbed the two of them so much that they almost broke up three times in the car on the way home (once when one of them blamed the other for “her friend”—me—playing such a horrible prank on them, the second when the other blamed the first for being friends with me, and the third just because they were being emotional) and wanted to lecture me about how horrible and homophobic the movie was, and how men may not understand this but lesbians do not have any interest in men! Harrumph! (Postscript: one of them is now married to a man). So yeah.
Lest we assume from that anecdote that only lesbian couples will react this badly to Chasing Amy, an apparently straight woman I watched it with later told me as she rolled her eyes “you only like this because it’s about lesbians . . . god, men are all alike.” Steer clear. It also hasn't aged very well.
(4) The Hunt For Red October (dir. John McTiernan)—1990
This one’s strictly speculative, and it’s admittedly standing in for a litany of—for the purposes under discussion—interchangeable military-themed pictures, and this one wins the prize for being one of my favorites. But I can’t imagine being sober and/or remotely giving a shit and suggesting to a date that we watch this. Unless there’s some girl out there who gets all squirmy at the sound of James Earl Jones saying, “Now understand, the torpedo did not detonate, you heard it hit the hull. And I . . . was never here.” (If you do, e-mail me). The exquisite pleasures of watching fiercely intelligent men match wits, maverick Soviet sub captains evading capture and certain death from all sides, callow young CIA analysts struggling to earn the trust of veteran military men, and ultimately basking quietly in a shared victory are in completely separate categories from the exquisite pleasures of taking women to bed. Do not mix.
(3) Sid and Nancy (dir. Alex Cox)—1986
As with (4), this one is standing in for any number of movies with a similar problem, but this goes one higher on the list because while gay military nerds might get simultaneous boners to all the talk about Crazy Ivans and so forth, watching a couple get so fucked up on drugs that the guy fatally stabs the girl is not getting anyone hot. Not to mention, Pistols purists occasionally gripe about the liberties Alex Cox took with the historical record in favor of hallucinatory visuals and general narrative drive, so try and seduce them some other way. Still, that caveat aside, it’s a great movie, and endlessly quotable, but when one of the best quotes is “None of us fuck, see? Sex is ugly,” it’s maybe kind of sort just slightly advisable to not try and get someone turned on with this one. Try, I don’t know, Trainspotting, that at least has Ewan McGregor’s dick in it.
(2) Caddyshack (dir. Harold Ramis)—1980*
Now, I know what you’re thinking—Rodney does cap the proceedings by announcing: “Hey, everybody. We’re all gonna get laid!” And yes, that is the greatest last line in a movie ever. But, reasonable as it may seem to turn to your girl after Rodney says the line and say to her, “So . . . is he right?” I would advise against. Also, this is the one movie I can think of that I have absolutely never met a woman who liked it. At all. I speak as a guy who has made out with a girl while watching Slap Shot and even—put the bullshit detector away, please—once met a girl who liked Bloodsport. So as an expert on such matters, do not, gentlemen, ask your girl to sit through Caddyshack. You will not be pleased with the results.
(2a) Fried Green Tomatoes (dir. Jon Avnet)—1991
Since the above paragraph was directed solely to men, a word for the ladies: making a guy watch this movie is like taking him shopping. Now, I’m a progressive guy, and as sophisticated a cineaste as you’re going to find anywhere (the ten “fucks” per sentence and wide-eyed fascination with explosions and car chases notwithstanding). This is a well-made movie. It’s got a terrific cast. I am not in any way shape or form knocking it as a movie. But as an experience, if you’re not a woman, this movie is not interested in you. Never mind that a guy directed it. A woman directed Point Break, after all. I had an ex put Fried Green Tomatoes on once, and she woke me up to complain that she’d wanted to watch a movie as a romantic evening together. Let the record reflect that it did not work.
(2) and (2a) are part of the same point—any movie that caters entirely to the interests of one gender fails as a date movie. Apologies for any slight to gay couples, but the same principle would apply to any movie with an aggressively and exclusively heteronormative viewpoint, or, worse, an openly homophobic one. I’d come up with a specific example, but as I said before, the only gay guy I watch a lot of movies with spends all his time trying to figure out whether Dario Argento or Takashi Miike is the greatest director of all time and I'm still persona non grata with the lesbians over shit like the Chasing Amy trolling, so I don’t really have a normal demographic sample to work with here.
(1) Knocked Up (dir. Judd Apatow)—2007
The absolute worst date movie imaginable. Forget for a second that Judd Apatow movies are all too long, and his process—building the movie around improvised scenes—inexorably leads to a loose, digressive narrative structure. Hell, John Cassavetes movies are all too long, what are you gonna do, call the cops? Forget also that in spite of at least one hilarious scene per movie (i.e. “You know how I know you’re gay?” or “Munich is going to get us laid!”) there are just as invariably excruciatingly long stretches of maudlin sentimentality or leaden moodiness in each one. That could happen to anybody, and as the man said, dying is easy, comedy’s hard. No, that’s not the worst. Hell, 40 Year Old Virgin is actually not a bad date movie, all things considered. But Knocked Up has a number of jaw-droppers in store for a couple going to see it on their first or second date:
--The whole story revolves around a fun, drunken hookup wherein the guy gets the girl pregnant. In and of itself that would make it the worst date movie ever, but it doesn’t stop there.
--All the guys are emotionally retarded pussies.
--The women don’t fare much better. Katherine Heigl’s ok, and you gotta cut her some slack for being pissed off about getting pregnant, which sucks, but holy shit Leslie Mann got stuck with a thankless part. All she does the whole movie is either scream at people or cry. She’s such a fascistic wife that Paul Rudd has to sneak off to his fantasy baseball draft like it was an adulterous affair.
--The ultimate conclusion seems to be that men are emotionally stunted boy-pupae who with the help of a woman telling them what do to, can blossom into husband-butterflies.
Now, it can be argued—probably pretty easily—that I’m overreacting, that that’s not what Judd Apatow is saying. That’s not the point (and it’s not just not the point because it’s flimsy bullshit). The clincher is: there was a lot of talk in the media when Knocked Up came out about it provoking serious conversations between couples who went to see it on dates. This is why it’s the worst date movie ever. Serious conversations???? Serious conversations are for when you’re already in a relationship. Dates are supposed to be about going out, having a good time—drinking, dancing, eating good food, having a laugh, getting in adventures, etc.—not sitting around debating the nature of gender roles in modern society.
Not only that, but the biggest problem with all the men in Knocked Up being pussies/retards/both and all the women being angry/dictatorial/pathologically vague about their wants is that, unlike (2) and (2a) where at least one person is being entertained, both of you are being insulted.
* * * *
In the end, the solution is to either date someone who likes the same kind of movies you do, trade off who gets to pick the movie, or just avoid the minefield altogether and think of something else to do. Don’t ask me what that is; if I knew I wouldn’t be writing a movie blog.
****
*(EDIT (1/11/10): The other night my friends Hope Cartelli and Jessi Gotta brought it to my attention that this is bullshit: they're both women and they both love Caddyshack. Moreover, Jessi tells me it was her mother who got her into it. So, a revision: only really cool girls like Caddyshack.)
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)


